Study finds Grade 8 learners carry the heaviest schoolbags

As learners prepare to return to school in January 2027, new research from the North-West University (NWU) raises an important question for parents and schools: are teenagers carrying more than they need to?

A study of 186 South African adolescents aged 12 to 18 found that Grade 8 learners carried the heaviest schoolbags relative to their body weight. Their bags weighed an average of 10,6 kg, compared with 6 kg among Grade 7 learners.

More than two-thirds (67%) of the Grade 8 learners in the study carried schoolbags with more than 15% of their body mass. Across the full group, 58% carried bags exceeding this level.Published in the Journal of Applied Biomechanics, the research found that carrying a schoolbag changed the adolescents’ walking patterns and increased the forces and pressures placed on their feet.

Although the study did not establish that heavy schoolbags cause injuries or pain, the findings highlight the physical demands that carrying heavy loads can place on growing teenagers.

What happens when learners carry heavy schoolbags?

The researchers measured the adolescents’ walking patterns both with and without their schoolbags, using a pressure platform to examine how their feet responded.

The results showed that carrying a schoolbag changed the way the adolescents walked. They spent more time with their feet on the ground and with both feet supporting their bodies, while the forces and pressures on different parts of their feet increased.

The researchers also found that the heavier the schoolbag was relative to a learner’s body mass, the greater the forces and pressures recorded around the heel and forefoot.

These findings suggest that schoolbag mass deserves greater attention, particularly during early adolescence, when learners are moving into high school and may face different textbook and learning-material requirements.

The researchers caution that the study measured changes in walking patterns and foot loading. It did not establish whether these changes lead to pain, fatigue or injury over time.

A closer look at the Grade 7 to Grade 8 transition

One of the most striking findings was the increase in schoolbag weight between Grades 7 and 8.

The average bag mass increased from 6 kg in Grade 7 to 10,6 kg in Grade 8, a difference of 4,6 kg. Grade 8 learners also carried the heaviest loads relative to their body mass, with schoolbags averaging 18,4% of their body mass.

With a new school year approaching, the findings raise practical questions about how much learning material learners need to transport between home and school each day.

Parents and schools could consider whether all textbooks and materials need to be carried daily, or whether some could be kept in classrooms or lockers where facilities allow. Schools could also review how learning materials are organised to help learners avoid carrying unnecessary items.

These are possible ways to reduce the daily load, although the study did not test specific solutions or prescribe a single schoolbag weight limit.

Differences between boys and girls

The study also found differences in how male and female adolescents responded to schoolbag loads.

Although boys and girls did not differ significantly in the mass of the schoolbags they carried, female participants recorded higher peak pressures in the forefoot and midfoot and tended to walk with a narrower step width.

The researchers caution that these differences should not automatically be interpreted as evidence of pain or injury. Further research is needed to determine whether the observed changes have meaningful effects on health over time.

The findings highlight the importance of understanding how schoolbag loads affect adolescents at different stages of development.

Why the research matters in South Africa

Much of the existing research on schoolbag biomechanics has been conducted in high-income countries. This study adds evidence from South African adolescents and provides insight into how carrying schoolbags affects their walking patterns.

More specifically, the research involved 186 injury-free adolescent boys and girls aged 12 to 18 years from three primary schools in the Potchefstroom area. Participants completed walking trials both with and without their schoolbags while researchers recorded changes in their walking patterns and the forces acting on their feet.

As families prepare for the 2027 school year, the findings provide an opportunity for parents, teachers and schools to reconsider whether learners are carrying more than they need to and how unnecessary loads might be reduced.

The central message is not that schoolbags are harmful in themselves, but that their weight deserves attention, particularly among younger adolescents carrying relatively heavy loads.

About the study

The study, “The Influence of Relative Schoolbag Mass on Gait Biomechanics of South African Adolescents: The Role of Sex and Grade”, was conducted by Clément N. Gambelli, Suleen Peens, Andries F. van Oort and Mark Kramer from the NWU’s Physical Activity, Sport and Recreation Focus Area (PhASRec). Clément is also affiliated with the Laboratory of Physiology and Biomechanics of Locomotion at Université Catholique de Louvain in Belgium.

The research was funded by the PhASRec.

Useful tips 

  1. How can parents check if their children's schoolbags are too heavy?
    Parents can easily determine the schoolbag mass on a scale. Knowing their child’s mass, they can divide the schoolbag’s mass (e.g., 10 kg) by the child’s mass (e.g., 50 kg) and multiply by 100 to obtain the relative schoolbag mass (e.g., 10 / 50 * 100 = 20%). In this instance, their child would be carrying a school bag that weighs 20% of their body mass. This is what hiker’s typically carry when they go on multi-day hikes in the wilderness!
     

  2. What can schools do to reduce the number of books and other materials learners need to carry every day?
    The schools should ideally organise lockers or a place where each child can leave some of their school material. Teachers should indicate which material the children need to carry home only to do the homework for the next day, nothing more. 
     

  3. Is there a recommended schoolbag weight limit for teenagers, and what does the 15% of body weight figure mean in practice?
    Most studies in the scientific literature studied schoolbag carriage in children below 12 years old. Previous research has shown that carrying above 15 % body mass induces significant changes in walking pattern, especially force and pressure under the feet, but also changes in posture that could potentially lead to long-term musculoskeletal disorders.
     

  4. Does using both shoulder straps and adjusting the bag properly help? What other advice would you give to learners?
    Using both straps helps distribute the load more symmetrically across the shoulders, whereas carrying a bag on one shoulder can increase asymmetrical shoulder loading, alter trunk posture and increase discomfort. While a direct link is difficult to establish, the researchers believe that using only one strap, especially with the high schoolbag load recorded in the current study, could potentially lead to long-term musculoskeletal imbalances or disorders such as scoliosis. 

    Strap adjustment is also important because it influences the position and stability of the bag, the forces acting on the shoulders and the postural adjustments required to carry the load. However, evidence does not establish that incorrect backpack use directly causes long-term back pain in all adolescents. Therefore, using both straps and adjusting them appropriately are sensible ergonomic practices to improve load distribution and comfort, alongside keeping the backpack as light as practicable.
     

  5. What should parents look out for if their children experience discomfort when carrying a schoolbag?
    First, calculate the relative schoolbag’s mass relative to the child’s mass. If it is above 15%, discuss with the school to find a solution to reduce it. Second, ask the child and observe how he/she carries it, and advise them to carry it on both shoulders with straps properly adjusted. Third, check if the schoolbag’s size is appropriate for the child. Most children and adolescents carry schoolbags that are too big or not appropriate for their stature.

 

Submitted on